Michigan’s Religious Bullying Bill

With the reproductive health bill still stuck in legislation, our legislators need a lesson or two about religious freedom. But I hope they don’t follow Michigan’s example.

Michigan recently passed an anti-bullying bill, but instead of discouraging bullies, the bill seems to empower them with a familiar excuse: religion. The bill allows bullying so long as it’s done in the name of God. Anti-bullying? The bill should have been named “Religious Bullying.”

Imagine the following scene:

Harvey: Teacher, teacher! Billy is calling me names and throwing rocks at me!
Teacher: Why are you doing this, Harvey?
Billy: Because Harvey’s a homo!
Teacher: Who told you it’s OK to do this?
Billy: My dad told me that God told him it’s OK, and God hates fags!
Teacher: Oh, in that case, carry on then.

Ironically, the Religious Bullying bill is called “Matt’s Safe School Law,” after Matt Epling, a bullied student who killed himself in 2002. Understandably, Matt’s father is not happy:

Matt’s father, Kevin Epling, expressed his dismay in a Facebook post after the state senate vote on Wednesday. “I am ashamed that this could be Michigan’s bill on anti-bullying,” wrote Epling. “For years the line [from Republicans] has been ‘no protected classes,’ and the first thing they throw in…was a very protected class, and limited them from repercussions of their own actions.”

Last year, in the span of around a month, at least five teens committed suicide because they were bullied for being gay. States such as Michigan are trying to respond, but I doubt that sectarian solutions such as the Religious Bullying bill will do anything to prevent incidents like this from happening. On the contrary, it gives a religious justification to actual bullies and a religious motivation to potential ones.

And Michigan students do not need a law to motivate them to bully homosexuals. They only need to follow their parents’ examples:

At the federal level, they unsuccessfully fought for the inclusion of a provision protecting religious freedom when Congress expanded the definition of a hate crime to include crimes motivated by a victim’s sexual orientation. They also strongly oppose legislation that would prevent discrimination against gay individuals in the workplace, charging that such a law would endanger religious freedom. A report on the Christian Broadcasting Network outlined one such concern: “The special protections for gay and transgendered teachers will make it extremely difficult for [public school] districts that might want to remove them from the classroom.”

In the Philippines, Catholic bullies use religious freedom to justify kicking out unwed pregnant mothers from Catholic schools. They use religious freedom to justify denying even non-Catholics the right to remarry. They use religious freedom to justify denying homosexuals the right to marry and be free from discrimination and violence. And to block the passage of the RH Bill, they use religious freedom to justify denying Filipinos their right to plan their families, protect themselves from HIV and pregnancy complications, and choose what’s best for their own bodies.

As Amy Sullivan wrote, they’re getting religious freedom wrong:

Social conservatives believe that efforts to protect gays from assault, discrimination or bullying impinge on their religious freedom to express and act on their belief that homosexuality is an abomination…

This belief, however, relies on a warped understanding of religious liberty. Freedom of religious expression doesn’t give someone the right to kick the crap out of a gay kid or to verbally torment her. It doesn’t give someone the right to fire a gay employee instead of dealing with the potential discomfort of working with him…

The same religious conservatives who applaud the religious exemption in Michigan’s anti-bullying bill would be appalled if it protected a Muslim student in Dearborn who defended bullying a Christian classmate by saying he considered her an infidel.

Worst of all, such abuses of the concept of religious liberty undermine efforts to focus attention on serious threats to religious freedom. A Christian pastor in Iran currently faces execution because he will not convert back to Islam. China openly represses religious minorities like Tibetan Buddhists and Uighur Muslims. Christians in Syria and Egypt continue to be targets of violence, and Muslims in Europe face civil penalties for wearing religious garb in public. Next to these realities, it takes a serious persecution complex to get worked up about defending the right of a Michigan high school student to target a gay classmate for ridicule.

I hope our legislators take the time to read Michigan’s Religious Bullying Bill. It serves as a perfect example of how religious freedom is done wrong.

4 comments

  1. One loophole I can find out of the legislation:

    Claim that one's religious beliefs mandate that they beat the living shit out of anybody who bullies them.

  2. Red, thank you for your interest in this issue. It is interesting to read the perspective from one on the other side of the Ocean. Thanks to the outrage on the Internet, and 'thousands' of letters from Michigan students, it looks like the language of SB 137 will be changed. The attention actually does some good when people listen! Click the link and watch the video for more. http://www.mlive.com/education/index.ssf/2011/11/… Thanks again Filipino Freethinkers!

  3. It's called the "Universal" Church after all, they think the universe is theirs.

    To the most extreme among them, anything and anyone who does not conform to their beliefs should be harassed, similar to how muslim extremists believe it's their duty to kill infidels.

  4. Please join in the online awareness campaign to fix this bill. Religion should never be made into an excuse for hurting other people.

    Copy, share, and disseminate to all your social networks:

    From M.Monica's blog post: Who Would Jesus Bully?

    The Michigan legislature is about to pass an anti-bullying law that says in the law that bullying is ok if you do it for "religious reasons."

    This is outrageous. It will contribute to the high rate of GLBT teen harassment. Many teens have even committed suicide because of being harassed for being gay, lesbian, or transgender. This bill would make it a protected right to bully others because of religion or gender. Those who could also be affected include Jewish students, minorities of any type, or athiest children.

    If you disagree with this law, please email these people below. Please do this even if you live out of state or in a country other than the USA. You may want to mention that you will not visit Michigan or spend any money there if this bill making bullying a legal right passes. The bill name is Senate Bill No. 137.

    Email:

    Michigan's governor, Rick Snyder, at [email protected]
    Speaker of the House: [email protected]

    If you live in the state of Michigan, find your representative here and email them: http://www.house.mi.gov/mhrpublic/

    Help stop this bill and you could be saving the lives of many people who are bullied to the point of suicide. Please do it if you have a gay friend. Please do it if you know someone who knows someone who does. Please do it if you truly believe in what Christianity is really about- "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone."

    Feel free to reshare. The Michigan House will vote on this bill soon.

    ——-
    source: https://plus.google.com/117665613028757061169/pos

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here